Power & Distribution

How to size a neutral grounding resistor (NGR): let-through current, ohms and time rating (NEC 250.36, CEC 10-302)

Billy, Entogo

Industrial process plant power distribution where a neutral grounding resistor limits ground-fault current on a resistance-grounded 480 V or 4.16 kV system

Photo — Budget Bizar · Pexels · Pexels License

Key takeaways

  • An NGR is sized from R = V(line-to-neutral) ÷ I(let-through); at 480 V a 5 A high-resistance system needs 277.1 ÷ 5 = 55.4 ohms.
  • The let-through current must be at or above the system charging current 3·Ic0, or arcing ground faults can drive transient overvoltages; systems below 600 V typically run 1 to 3 A.
  • NEC 250.36 permits impedance grounding from 480 V to 1 kV only with qualified maintenance, ground detectors and no line-to-neutral loads, and a neutral conductor of at least 8 AWG copper.
  • In Canada a resistance-grounded system may stay energized on a first ground fault only at 5 kV or less, with no neutral loads and fault current held to 10 A or less (CEC Rule 10-302).
  • A high-resistance NGR must be continuously rated; a 480 V, 5 A unit dissipates 277.1 × 5 = 1386 W for as long as the fault stays on.
  • A 4.16 kV low-resistance NGR at 400 A is 6.0 ohms and absorbs about 9.6 MJ over a 10-second rating, so it is short-time rated per IEEE Std 32 duty classes.

A neutral grounding resistor (NGR) is three numbers on a nameplate: the let-through current, the resistance in ohms and the time rating. Get the current wrong and the resistor either fails to damp arcing-fault overvoltages or lets through enough current to burn the fault point. The method is short. Estimate the system charging current, set the let-through current at or above it, and divide the line-to-neutral voltage by that current. A 480 V high-resistance system at 5 A needs 277.1 ÷ 5 = 55.4 Ω, continuously rated, which is 1386 W for as long as the fault stays on. A 4.16 kV low-resistance system at 400 A needs 6.0 Ω with a 10-second rating. The scheme choice itself (solid, high-resistance, low-resistance) is covered in choosing a power system grounding scheme. This page sizes the resistor once that choice is made, using the same transformer full-load and fault-current figures the transformer sizing calculator produces.

What does an NGR actually limit?

On a solidly grounded wye, a line-to-ground fault is a short circuit, limited only by the transformer and conductor impedance. An NGR between the transformer neutral and the grounding electrode conductor replaces that path with a known resistance. The ground-fault current then becomes a design value instead of whatever the system can deliver. Eaton’s application paper puts the solidly grounded figure for a 480 V system served by a 1500 kVA transformer at 29,200 A. With high-resistance grounding the same fault is held to 10 A or less, and with low-resistance grounding it is generally 200 A to 1200 A.

Two physical limits bound the choice:

  • Floor: the charging current. Even an ungrounded system carries a ground-fault current through the phase-to-ground capacitance of cables, motors and surge capacitors. EC&M states that the resistor current “must be greater than the system capacitive charging current to avoid transient overvoltages.” The Informational Note to NEC 250.36(C) says the same thing: a value “equal to or somewhat above” the charging current.
  • Ceiling: what the code lets you run on. If the plant is to stay energized on a first fault, the current has to stay low enough to cause no appreciable damage. Canada caps it at 10 A (below). Above that, the fault must be tripped, which makes the system low-resistance grounded.

How do you estimate the charging current?

The charging current is the phasor sum of the currents returning through the two unfaulted phases’ capacitance to ground:

3·Ic0 = 3 × V(L-N) ÷ Xc0, with Xc0 = 1 ÷ (2π × f × C0)

where C0 is the total phase-to-ground capacitance per phase. Eaton’s 480 V example uses Xc0 = 800 Ω per phase and finds 1.04 A (2 × 0.6 A × cos 30°); the formula above gives the same 3 × 277.1 ÷ 800 = 1.04 A. There are three ways to get the charging current. You can calculate it from the cable and equipment capacitance in the design. You can use resistor-manufacturer estimation tables. Or you can use EC&M’s screening rule of roughly 1 A per 1000 kVA of source capacity; EC&M also gives a typical 1 A to 3 A for systems below 600 V. EC&M also says the value should be confirmed by an actual measurement at commissioning. Between 600 V and 5 kV, charging current “can vary from 1A to 10A.” Above 5 kV it “may be greater than 25A,” which is why low-resistance grounding is almost always used there.

Which time rating and let-through current fit each system?

The rule table below summarizes how practice and code set the current and the duty for each system class.

SystemGroundingTypical let-through currentTime ratingWhat sets it
480Y/277 V, no L-N loadsHigh-resistance5 A typical, ≤ 10 AContinuous≥ 3·Ic0 (NEC 250.36(C) Info Note)
600 V three-wire (347/600 V wye, neutral not distributed)High-resistance5 A, ≤ 10 A in CanadaContinuousCEC Rule 10-302 ride-through limit
2.4–4.16 kV, run on first faultHigh-resistance≥ 3·Ic0, ≤ 10 A in CanadaContinuousCharging current 1–10 A (EC&M)
4.16–13.8 kV, trip on faultLow-resistance200–400 A (200–1200 A range)10 s typicalRelay pickup and coordination
Charging current above 10 ALow-resistance or split system≥ 3·Ic0Short-timeEaton AP083005EN
Generator neutralHigh- or hybrid5 A to 400 ABy duty (ride-through or trip)EC&M generator practice

The time ratings come from IEEE Std 32 (now maintained as IEEE C57.32). The federal UFGS 16311A guide specification offers the specifier a 10-second, 1-minute, 10-minute or extended-time duty, and notes that ratings longer than 10 seconds are needed “only when the system is not taken off line by a ground fault, but merely monitored.” A high-resistance unit that carries the fault until maintenance finds it must therefore be continuously rated.

Worked example: 2000 kVA, 480Y/277 V high-resistance system

A process plant takes a 2000 kVA, 13.8 kV to 480Y/277 V pad-mounted transformer (2000 kVA size page). It feeds a three-wire motor lineup and has no line-to-neutral loads, so it qualifies for high-resistance grounding under NEC 250.36. The design calculation gives a total phase-to-ground capacitance of 4.0 µF per phase across cables, motors and surge capacitors.

  1. Line-to-neutral voltage. 480 ÷ √3 = 277.1 V. This is the voltage across the resistor during a bolted ground fault.
  2. Charging current. Xc0 = 1 ÷ (2π × 60 × 4.0 × 10⁻⁶) = 663.1 Ω per phase; 3 × 277.1 ÷ 663.1 = 1.254 A. Screening check: 2000 kVA × 1 A per 1000 kVA = 2.0 A, so 1.254 A is plausible.
  3. Let-through current. It must be at least 1.254 A, and it should stay well under the 10 A ride-through ceiling. Choose the common 5 A, which is 5 ÷ 1.254 = 3.99 × the charging current.
  4. Resistance. R = 277.1 ÷ 5 = 55.4 Ω, with insulation rated for at least the 277 V line-to-neutral voltage.
  5. Total ground-fault current. The resistive and capacitive currents add in quadrature: √(5² + 1.254²) = √26.57 = 5.155 A. The ground detector and the pulsing locator must be set against that figure.
  6. Continuous dissipation. P = 277.1 × 5 = 1386 W (equivalently 5² × 55.4 Ω). The enclosure and its location must shed about 1.4 kW indefinitely.
  7. Neutral conductor. The ampacity must be at least 5 A, but NEC 250.36(B) sets a floor of 8 AWG copper or 6 AWG aluminum, so the conductor is 8 AWG copper, fully insulated.
  8. Pulsing tap. A pulsing contactor that shorts half the resistor drops it to 55.4 ÷ 2 = 27.7 Ω, and the fault current then alternates between 5 A and 277.1 ÷ 27.7 = 10.0 A. That pulse is what a clamp-on ammeter follows to the faulted feeder, and it stays within a 10 A limit.

Step 2 — system charging current 3·Ic0

I3 = 3 * (V / sqrt(3)) * 2 * 3.14159265 * f * C * 0.000001

I3 = 1.254 A

Step 4 — NGR resistance

R = V / sqrt(3) / I

R = 55.43 ohm

Step 5 — total ground-fault current

Ig = sqrt(IR ^ 2 + IC ^ 2)

Ig = 5.155 A

Step 6 — continuous resistor dissipation

P = V / sqrt(3) * I

P = 1,386 W

R = V(L-N) ÷ I(let-through) = V(L-L) ÷ (√3 × I)

P = V(L-N) × I = I² × R

The transformer side of this example, 2000 kVA at 480 V, gives 2 000 000 ÷ (√3 × 480) = 2405.6 A of secondary full-load current. That is the figure the transformer sizing calculator reports and the basis for the protection rules in sizing transformer overcurrent protection. The NGR does not change the three-phase fault duty. It changes only the ground-fault duty, from thousands of amps to about 5 A.

Results for the example

QuantityValueBasis
Line-to-neutral voltage277.1 V480 ÷ √3
Charging current 3·Ic01.254 A4.0 µF per phase, 60 Hz
Let-through current5 A≥ 3·Ic0, ≤ 10 A
Resistance55.4 Ω277.1 ÷ 5
Total ground-fault current5.155 A√(5² + 1.254²)
Continuous dissipation1386 W277.1 × 5
Pulsing current10.0 A277.1 ÷ 27.7 Ω
Neutral conductor8 AWG CuNEC 250.36(B) floor
Time ratingContinuousNot tripped on first fault

Second example: 4.16 kV low-resistance system, 400 A for 10 s

A 3000 kVA, 13.8 kV to 4.16Y/2.4 kV transformer at 5.75 %Z (percent impedance) feeds medium-voltage motors through metal-clad switchgear. Each feeder relay trips ground faults selectively, so the system is low-resistance grounded at 400 A.

  1. Full-load current: 3 000 000 ÷ (√3 × 4160) = 416.4 A.
  2. Infinite-source three-phase fault: 416.4 ÷ 0.0575 = 7241 A.
  3. Resistance: 2401.8 ÷ 400 = 6.0 Ω.
  4. Ground fault as a share of the three-phase fault: 400 ÷ 7241 = 5.5 %, inside the 5–20 % band Eaton lists for low-resistance grounding.
  5. Energy over the rating: 2401.8 × 400 × 10 s = 9607 kJ. The resistor element is sized for that pulse, so a 10-second rating applies, and the relay must clear well inside it.

MV example — energy absorbed over a 10 s rating

E = V / sqrt(3) * I * t / 1000

E = 9,607 kJ

Where Canada differs

The NEC and the CEC agree on the arithmetic but not on the envelope. NEC 250.36 (retitled “Impedance grounded systems — 480 V to 1 kV” in the 2023 edition) permits ride-through grounding with qualified persons, ground detectors and no line-to-neutral loads. It states no ampere limit; the Informational Note points to the charging current. CEC Rule 10-302 lets a system remain energized on a ground fault only at 5 kV or less, with no neutral loads, fault current controlled to 10 A or less and a continuously rated grounding device. The 2006 edition carried the same 10 A / 5 kV test in Rule 10-1102(2), raised from 5 A in 2002. Since the 2018 edition, Rule 10-302 also requires protection against grounding-device failure, with detection of an open or shorted NGR mandatory; the 2021 edition dropped the requirement to trip immediately. A 347/600 V system that serves 347 V lighting uses its neutral, so it falls outside the ride-through test. Confirm the subrule wording against CSA C22.1:2024 and the AHJ.

CEC case — 600 V high-resistance NGR at 5 A

R = V / sqrt(3) / I

R = 69.28 ohm

Reference: NGR ohms and watts by system voltage

R = V(L-N) ÷ I and P = V(L-N) × I. This table is the bookmark version of every example above.

System (L-L)V(L-N)1 A2 A5 A10 A200 A400 A
480 V277.1 V277.1 Ω138.6 Ω55.4 Ω / 1.39 kW27.7 Ω / 2.77 kW——
600 V346.4 V346.4 Ω173.2 Ω69.3 Ω / 1.73 kW34.6 Ω / 3.46 kW——
4.16 kV2401.8 V2401.8 Ω1200.9 Ω480.4 Ω / 12.0 kW240.2 Ω / 24.0 kW12.0 Ω6.0 Ω
13.8 kV7967.4 V———796.7 Ω / 79.7 kW39.8 Ω19.9 Ω
RequirementNEC (2023)CEC (CSA C22.1)
Ride-through scope250.36, 480 V to 1 kVRule 10-302, 5 kV or less
Ampere limit to stay energizedNo ampere limit stated; ≥ charging current10 A or less
Neutral loadsNot permitted (250.36)Not permitted for ride-through
Device dutyMatched to fault durationContinuously rated for ride-through
Neutral-to-NGR conductor≥ NGR rating, ≥ 8 AWG Cu / 6 AWG AlSized to the device, ≥ 8 AWG (former Rule 10-1108)
Above 1 kV250.187, insulated for max neutral voltageNo ride-through above 5 kV (Rule 10-302)
Device failureGround detectors requiredOpen and short NGR detection (Rule 10-302)

What to specify

  • System charging current 3·Ic0, from the cable and equipment capacitance study, checked against 1 A per 1000 kVA and confirmed by measurement at commissioning (NEC 250.36 Informational Note).
  • Let-through current, at or above 3·Ic0 and at or below 10 A where a Canadian system must ride through (CEC Rule 10-302), or the relay pickup for low-resistance systems.
  • Resistance and voltage rating, R = V(L-N) ÷ I and insulation of at least the line-to-neutral voltage, from the transformer nameplate secondary voltage.
  • Time rating: continuous for high-resistance, 10 s (or 1 min / 10 min) for low-resistance, per IEEE Std 32 duty classes and the relay clearing time from the coordination study.
  • Neutral-to-NGR conductor, ≥ NGR rating and ≥ 8 AWG copper (NEC 250.36(B); ≥ 8 AWG under the former CEC Rule 10-1108), plus the bonding and grounding electrode conductors from the grounding electrode conductor sizing method.
  • Monitoring: ground detector, pulsing locator and open/short NGR supervision, with space and wiring provided in the low-voltage switchgear and MCC or the transformer secondary section.

Common mistakes

  • Choosing 1 A because “lower is safer”. If 3·Ic0 is 1.254 A, a 1 A resistor sits below the charging current and no longer damps arcing faults. The correct minimum is ≥ 1.254 A, and 5 A is typical. The NEC 250.36 Informational Note and a commissioning measurement catch it.
  • Using line-to-line voltage in R = V ÷ I. 480 ÷ 5 = 96 Ω gives only 2.9 A, below the intended 5 A. The resistor sees 277.1 V, so 55.4 Ω is correct. A nameplate check of “277 V, 5 A, 55.4 Ω” catches it.
  • Specifying a 10-second resistor on a ride-through system. A high-resistance unit carries 1386 W until maintenance clears the fault. A short-time element will overheat, so it must be continuously rated, as CEC Rule 10-302 requires for ride-through, with the duty class named per IEEE Std 32.
  • Sizing the neutral conductor to the 5 A rating. A 14 AWG conductor carries 5 A but is below the 8 AWG copper floor of NEC 250.36(B). Specify 8 AWG copper, fully insulated.
  • Applying ride-through grounding to a 347/600 V lighting system. Neutral loads disqualify it under both NEC 250.36 and CEC Rule 10-302. Solid grounding applies instead, with ground-fault protection of equipment under NEC 230.95 where a service disconnect is rated 1000 A or more on a wye system above 150 V to ground.

Where Entogo fits

The NGR sits on the neutral of a transformer and reports to relays in the switchgear, so the three are specified together. Entogo supplies three-phase pad-mounted transformers designed and built to IEEE C57.12.00 / C57.12.34, and metal-clad switchgear designed and built to ANSI/IEEE C37.20.2. It also supplies compact secondary unit substations with the neutral bushing and NGR connection provisions set before shipment. All of these are UL (cULus)/CSA certifiable on request. The NGR itself is specified from the numbers above and supplied by a resistor manufacturer; the neutral bushing and the relay and monitoring interface in the switchgear are fixed at order to match it.

Start with the transformer kVA and secondary current in the transformer sizing calculator, carry them into the transformer configurator, and see industrial EPC and substations and power distribution for packaged plant systems. For motor lineups behind an HRG transformer, see how to size a motor control center. For the downstream short-circuit ratings, see available fault current and SCCR.

Sizing an NGR takes four numbers in order: the charging current, a let-through current above it, the resistance at line-to-neutral voltage, and a time rating that matches whether the fault is tripped or carried. At 480 V that is 1.254 A, 5 A, 55.4 Ω and continuous; at 4.16 kV it is 400 A, 6.0 Ω and 10 seconds. In Canada the ride-through current stays at 10 A or less.

Sources

  1. EC&M, From the Ground Up (R = VL-N ÷ IR, charging current 1 to 3 A below 600 V, 10-second LRG rating)
  2. EEPower, National Electrical Code 2023 Basics, Grounding and Bonding Part 10 (NEC 250.36)
  3. EEPower, NEC Basics, Impedance-Grounded Systems and Equipment Grounding Above 1 kV (NEC 250.187)
  4. IAEI Magazine, CEC 2006 Neutral Grounding Devices, Rules 10-1100 to 10-1108
  5. Bender, Power System Design Challenges to Meet CE Code Rule 10-302
  6. Eaton Application Paper AP083005EN, Characteristics of different power systems neutral grounding techniques, fact and fiction
  7. UFGS 16311A, neutral grounding resistor per IEEE Std 32 (10-second, 1-minute, 10-minute, extended-time duty)
  8. I-Gard, Unparalleled Protection Electrical System Grounding (quotes CEC Rule 10-302 ride-through conditions; 480 V 5 A = 55.4 ohms)
  • Switchgear
  • Grounding
  • NEC 250
  • CEC Section 10
  • Fault current
  • Power & Distribution

Glossary: Pad-mounted transformer60 Hz vs. 50 HzPercent impedanceMetal-clad switchgearLow-voltage switchgearMotor control center

FAQ

Common questions

How many ohms is a neutral grounding resistor for a 480 V system?
Divide the line-to-neutral voltage by the let-through current. At 480 V the line-to-neutral voltage is 277.1 V, so a 5 A high-resistance unit is 55.4 ohms, a 2 A unit is 138.6 ohms and a 10 A unit is 27.7 ohms.
How do you choose the let-through current of a high-resistance grounding resistor?
Set it at or somewhat above the total system charging current 3·Ic0 so the resistor damps arcing-fault overvoltages. Systems below 600 V typically run 1 to 3 A of charging current, so 5 A is the common choice; measure the charging current at commissioning.
What time rating does a neutral grounding resistor need?
A high-resistance NGR that lets the plant run on a first ground fault must be continuously rated. A low-resistance NGR whose relay trips the fault is short-time rated, usually 10 seconds, with 1-minute, 10-minute and extended-time duties available under IEEE Std 32 (now IEEE C57.32).
What size is the conductor between the transformer neutral and the NGR?
Under NEC 250.36 the neutral-to-impedance conductor must be fully insulated, have an ampacity at least equal to the maximum current rating of the grounding impedance and be no smaller than 8 AWG copper or 6 AWG aluminum, so a 5 A NGR still takes 8 AWG copper.
Can a 600 V resistance-grounded system stay energized on a ground fault in Canada?
Yes, if the system is 5 kV or less, serves no neutral loads, limits ground-fault current to 10 A or less and uses a continuously rated grounding device. A 347/600 V system serving 347 V lighting has neutral loads, so it cannot use this ride-through.
How much ground-fault current does a 4.16 kV low-resistance grounded system allow?
Low-resistance systems are commonly set between 200 and 400 A and are generally sized at 1200 A or less. At 4.16 kV the line-to-neutral voltage is 2401.8 V, so 400 A needs 6.0 ohms and 200 A needs 12.0 ohms, both short-time rated, usually 10 seconds.

Keep reading

Related insights

Project inquiry

Turn the brief into a specified system.

Offline

Customer support

Offline

Our customer support team is currently offline. Please email us with your question or project details.

contact@entogo.ca

Email our team